Wednesday, February 21, 2007

Poison Woman

That woman--Catherine Deveny--is poisonous. Following an Archepiscopal telling off for her last foray into the subject of religion, she has thrown the fat into the fire with this rather nasty little diatribe.

She could hardly be more offensive if she tried to be. Do we really need to know what she would be willing to do on the consecrated altar of a church? And is this really journalism? Why did the editor of The Age feel justified in giving it column space? Is the article particularly insightful? No. Is it funny? No. Is Ms Deveny (as Jane Austen would say) "a person of information"? No. So what is the point of printing it? Maybe if Ms Deveny wants to write this sort of stuff she should start a blog. I don't pay my $1.50 each day to read this garbage.

But, let's cut her some slack. Perhaps Catherine Deveny is more sinned against than sinning, more "poisoned" than "poisonous". Judging by what she has written in both columns, she has not had a particularly positive experience of the Catholic religion. There could be anyone to blame for that--her parents, her priests, her school teachers, some nun somewhere--even (contra Monty Python) the Romans. It just goes to show that when we are in the business of evangelising (ie. telling the GOOD news) we sometimes (as a Church) are far better at communicating BAD news. And that's really tragic.

It would have been nice if she had, for instance, been given some decent biblical catechesis as a youngster, and then she would know a) how to read the infancy narratives of the Gospels, and b) how to read the legal codes of the Torah. It would also have been nice if, when she asked her priest why they didn't have altar girls in their parish, he had shown her some respect and at least attempted an explanation. After all, people don't respect institutions that don't respect them.

3 Comments:

At Wednesday, February 21, 2007 1:10:00 pm , Blogger Athanasius said...

It's never pleasant watching someone work out their neuroses in public, and this is no exception. Like you, I wondered at first why any editor would be interested. But then I remembered that there are plenty of ex-Catholic schoolkids out there who would be able to relate to this story.

(rant mode on)

Unfortunately, the level of catechesis she describes is the norm. My kids go to Catholic high schools, and they are frustrated by the infantile and content-free discussion in RE classes. Kids who have been in Catholic schools for years lack foundational knowledge of the faith and have no skills in moral reasoning beyond the lumpen-utilitarianism and emotivism they've picked up from the surrounding culture. Their embrace of that culture is therefore uncritical.

And why? Because they're taking their cues from us. It's our bourgeois lifestyles and commitments that they see, and it's not hard for kids to figure out what our real priorities are. And how can the occasional good teacher challenge that?

And the spiritual devastation of poor Ms Deveney is the result...

(rant mode off: sound of steam hissing)

 
At Wednesday, February 21, 2007 3:16:00 pm , Blogger Schütz said...

Couldn't agree more, old boy.

 
At Friday, February 23, 2007 1:56:00 pm , Blogger LYL said...

You *pay* to read The Age???!

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home