Friday, November 07, 2008

Dean Hoge is Dead

While were at it (as Neuhaus would say) Neuhaus also reports in his latest column that Dean Hoge is dead. Hoge was out here in Oz not all that long ago, and while he may have described himself as “as much Catholic as Protestant” , his acceptance of the idea of a "priestless Church" (and his eagerness to encourage the Australian Church to get ready for it) was very, very protestant and not at all Catholic.

Still, lets not speak ill of the dead. Let's comment on something else that Neuhaus comments on:
He [Hoge] also suggested that the way should be eased for Protestant clergy, married or unmarried, who want to become priests. “Now,” he said, “the process is long and arduous.” You will not be surprised that I agree with him on that. My way to becoming a Catholic was long and arduous, but, once that step was taken, the way to priesthood, thanks mainly to John Cardinal O’Connor, was not. But for many others that is not the case, and some very capable candidates have had to go through the entire seminary formation, as though they knew nothing about Catholicism, when, in fact, such converts typically have impressive pastoral experience and are frequently more knowledgeable about Catholic faith and life than those who have not had to think and pray their way into the Church.
Well, on second thoughts, perhaps I won't comment on that. I'll just let it stand.


At Friday, November 07, 2008 4:13:00 am , Anonymous Christine said...

May Dean Hoge rest in peace.

Having said that, a Presbyterian layman can't be as much "Catholic" as he is "Protestant".

Tip of the hat to Father Neuhaus though in his observation that converts to Catholicism are often more knowledgeable about Catholic faith and life than those who didn't have to think or pray their way into the Church.

At Friday, November 07, 2008 9:06:00 am , Blogger Past Elder said...

The Brave New Church. A Protestant scholar at The Catholic University of America is the pre-eminent scholar on the priesthood, based on -- sociology!

At Friday, November 07, 2008 10:30:00 am , Blogger Peter said...

The new eccumenism.

Step One: Define Catholic as adherance to the basics which 'everyone' agrees on

Step Two: Demonstrate that I adhere to these basics

Step Three: Conclude that I am, in fact, Catholic (and Methodist, and Baptist, and Anglican.)

At Sunday, November 09, 2008 3:51:00 pm , Blogger Schütz said...

And as Past Elder reminds us, the joke goes:

Q. When did you decide to become Catholic?
A. When I realised that I wasn't one.


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home